Ashton Aged Maduro #10 | Cigar Reviews by HB Cigars

How much does this thing cost again? Because at Fuente-adjacent pricing, I expected Fuente-adjacent quality control, not a draw tighter than your CFO's budget approval process. The Ashton Aged Maduro line has been around for over three decades, rolling out of Tabacalera A. Fuente with a Connecticut Broadleaf wrapper that gets fermented for up to three years before Carlito Fuente decides it's worthy of the Ashton name. "Many wrapper leaves are picked, but few are chosen" is their actual marketing copy, which sounds like a Hunger Games reboot nobody asked for. The #10 Robusto is their bread-and-butter size, and while the bread tastes fine, someone forgot to check if the butter was spreadable.

BUY DISCOUNT CIGARS HERE or ASHTONS HERE or RARE CIGARS HERE

🔥 THE VITALS 🔥

Cigar: Ashton Aged Maduro #10

Master Blender: Fuente

Size: 5" x 50 (Robusto)

Country of Origin: Dominican Republic

Factory: Tabacalera A. Fuente y Cia

Wrapper: Connecticut Broadleaf (Aged up to 3 years)

Binder: Dominican Republic

Filler: Dominican Republic

Price: $10-14 MSRP

Strength: Mild-Medium

🚀 WE ARE LIT!

Draw: Way too tight - like breathing through a coffee stirrer at altitude

Burn: Acceptable when it cooperates

Smoke Output: Above average when you can actually pull air through this thing

Ash: Good and solid - the one thing construction got right

The Connecticut Broadleaf wrapper presents dark as a moonless night with the kind of thickness that suggests quality but delivers frustration. The natural fermentation process that Ashton brags about creates genuine oiliness and that signature dark chocolate appearance that photographs well for Instagram even if it smokes like a clogged drain. Construction issues with the draw are documented across multiple reviews - even Cigar Aficionado's 92-point rating noted "the draw is a bit firm" which is reviewer-speak for "we'd complain more but they're advertisers." At this price point, a nail punch shouldn't be a mandatory accessory.

🎢 FLAVOR JOURNEY

FIRST THIRD: The Honeymoon Phase

cream, chocolate, slight pepper

Cream leads with chocolate in close pursuit, delivering the smooth maduro experience that justifies Ashton's three decades of reputation. Slight pepper announces itself on the retrohale without overstaying its welcome. The Connecticut Broadleaf is doing exactly what naturally fermented Broadleaf does - providing sweetness and depth that makes you understand why they age this wrapper for years. When you can actually get smoke through the restricted airway, the flavors are legitimately good. This is a cigar that knows what it wants to be; it's just being held hostage by whoever rolled it with the grip strength of a competitive arm wrestler.

SECOND THIRD: The Descent Begins

earth, espresso, charred wood, slight pepper(retro)

Earth emerges to darken the profile while espresso and charred wood add complexity that should elevate the experience. Pepper continues its subtle presence on the retrohale. The flavors are shifting in interesting directions - this is supposed to be the part where you nod appreciatively and consider box purchases. Instead, the tight draw is forcing harder pulls that heat the tobacco beyond optimal range, and no amount of purging resurrects the balance. The cigar is fighting against itself like a politician trying to explain their voting record. The espresso notes become more bitter than intended, the char less refined than charming.

FINAL THIRD: The Diminishing Returns

dark chocolate, earth, charred wood

Dark chocolate returns alongside persistent earth and charred wood, but the damage is done. What should be a satisfying conclusion feels like finishing a meal you've already given up on. The profile has compressed into a one-note earthiness that lacks the nuance of the opening act. Purging offers temporary relief before the problems reassemble like a horror movie villain. The wrapper that promised so much now tastes like it's punishing you for your optimism. You're not mad, you're just disappointed - the same thing your parents said about your career choices, except this time you paid $12 for the privilege.

BUY DISCOUNT CIGARS HERE or ASHTONS HERE or RARE CIGARS HERE

🏆 THE VERDICT:

B TIER

Flavor: B+

Construction: C

Availability: B

Price: C

Final Rating:

A tasty enough maduro that self-sabotages with construction issues that have no business appearing at this price point - proof that legacy brands can coast on reputation.

📊 BOTTOM LINE

The Ashton Aged Maduro #10 is a frustrating study in unrealized potential. The flavor profile showcases what three years of wrapper fermentation and Fuente factory pedigree can achieve - genuine cream, chocolate, and earth complexity that earns its mild-medium positioning. But the tight draw transforms what should be a relaxing smoke into a cardio exercise for your lungs, and the profile degradation as you progress suggests either inconsistent tobacco or my particular stick was rolled during someone's lunch break. At $10-14 per cigar, you're paying boutique prices for quality control that would embarrass a bundle brand. The Ashton name and Fuente production should guarantee better than this. Save your money for an actual Fuente or find a Broadleaf maduro that doesn't require a toolkit to enjoy.

TLDR: Connecticut Broadleaf that tastes better than it smokes - a three-decade legacy coasting on reputation while charging premium prices for budget construction.